"islamic" ethnography

topic posted Sun, March 7, 2004 - 10:48 PM by  daniel
Can anyone recommend some good ethnographies relating to Islam?

I think I've read everything by Lila Abu-Lughod.

Did Edmund Leach ever publish more on his Kashmir(?) fieldwork other than that (excellent) monograph? I don't remember it dealing with anything particularly "Islamic", but...

Is Gellner's thing any good?
posted by:
daniel
Dallas
  • Re: "islamic" ethnography

    Wed, March 10, 2004 - 8:55 PM
    Here is something overlooked by most people;"Go to anything by the people themselves!!!" (the very best source) It gives more truth and reality and less ideology,lies and warped theories....
    Being a Black Descendent of many Muslims,Moors,Etc.. i found this out after chasing the leaves in the wind for some years before getting my professorship.... (NOTE:The more Ancient the better and more pure the sources,for example The Islamic Way of life finds its roots in Egypt and Ethiopia through the sufi's and Original Black Jews from Ethiopia and even the Copts (Qupts),same people,also just for your info from one scientist to another-there are many people whom live an islamic way of life(ie:Natural),but are not muslim,so in other words this way of living pre-dates the "Religion" of Islam....)
    ***Hope i helped a little atleast to point you in the right direction??? Salom (Peace of mind and body unto you!) smile
  • Re: "islamic" ethnography

    Thu, March 11, 2004 - 6:33 AM
    Yes, Brenner's _Domestication of Desire_ looks really good, but if I understood its subject from the Amazon description in this case I'm looking for something that isn't so focused on issues of modernity and such per se. In any case, I'll definitely keep it in mind.

    I guess I'm actually looking for one of two things. Either a very rich, personal ethnography a la Abu-Lughod or a fairly low-level structuralist/functionalist approach that in some way addresses what is islamic about the group. I realize that easily can bring one back to issues of the modern, but... well, hopefully you know what I mean.
  • Re: "islamic" ethnography

    Fri, March 19, 2004 - 11:52 PM
    Geertz, gellner, Westermarck, Rabinow, and Eickelman are all goog for Morocco. I enjoy Gellner immensely, but Saints of the Atlas is about Amazigh Maraboutic Islam, and probably very different from Islam practiced elsewhere
  • Re: "islamic" ethnography

    Mon, June 5, 2006 - 6:53 PM
    Saba Mahmood just came out with an excellent book called the Politics of Piety. It's all about the women's islamiuc revival movement in Egypt. Good read, and really interesting to compare with the power, agency, and resistance stuff you find in Abu-Lughod.

    Also Stefania Pandolfo has a book out called Impasse of the Angels, its psycho anthro and med anthro in Morrocco

    Happy Reading
    • Re: "islamic" ethnography

      Mon, June 5, 2006 - 6:58 PM
      Also, although its not too much ethnography, in the end of the book you get some interesting ideas about Islam in Talal Asad's Geneologies of Religion.

      This book is really interesting if your into learning, reading, writing, about religion from an anthropological perspective. He makes some crucial points about religion as a category for study, that no anthropologist of religion should miss!

      Asad does alot of his work in Egypt as well, and writes about power, agency, laws, citizenship. Very interesting!!

Recent topics in "Anthropology"